Sleep Medicine Reviews
Volume 5, Issue 1 , Pages 33-46 , February 2001

Medico-legal aspects of sleep disorders: sleepiness and civil liability

  • Elizabeth Ellis

      Affiliations

    • Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia
    • ,
  • Ronald R Grunstein

      Affiliations

    • Centre for Respiratory Failure and Sleep Disorders and Sleep Research Group, Institute of Respiratory Medicine, Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, Missenden Rd Camperdown, Department of Medicine, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia

References 

  1. National Centre for Health Statistics, Vital Statistics of the United States 1997 Washington, 1998.
  2. Leger D. The cost of sleep related accidents: a report for the National Commission on Sleep Disorders Research. Sleep. 1994;17:84–93
  3. Road Safety Bureau of NSW, Problem definition and countermeasure summary: Fatigue 1993
  4. Gillberg M, Kecklund G, Akerstedt T. Sleepiness and performance of professional drivers in a truck simulator—comparisons between day and night driving. J Sleep Res. 1996;5:12–15
  5. George CF, Nickerson P, Hanley P, Millar T, Kryger M. Sleep apnea patients have more automobile accidents. Lancet. 1987;1:447
  6. Teran-Santos J, Jiminez-Gomez A, Cordero-Guevara J. the Co-operative Group Burgos-Santander. The association between sleep apnea and the risk of traffic accidents. N Engl J Med. 1999;340:847–851
  7. Conor AF, Young T, Suratt PM. Number of vehicle crashes attributable to sleep disordered breathing. Am J Resp Crit Care Med. 2000;161:A715
  8. Guilleminault C, Stooks R, Duncan S. Daytime sleepiness in regular heavy snorers. Chest. 1991;40–48
  9. Maycock G. Sleepiness and driving: the experience of heavy goods vehicle drivers in the UK. J Sleep Res. 1997;6:238–244
  10. George CFP, Boudreau AC, Smiley A. Comparison of simulated driving performance in narcolepsy and sleep apnea patients. Sleep. 1996;19:711–717
  11. American Thoracic Society . Sleep apnea, sleepiness and driving risk. Am J Respir Crit Care Med. 1994;150:1463–1473
  12. Aldrich MS. Narcolepsy. N Engld J Med. 1990;323:389–394
  13. O»Keefe R. Sleep disorders in the law of torts. J Law Med. 1996;3:283–295
  14. Jaensch v Coffey 155 Commonwealth Law Reports 549, 1984
  15. Hawkins v Clayton 164 Commonwealth Law Reports 539, 1988
  16. Council of the Shire of Wyong v Shirt 146 Commonwealth Law Reports 40, 1980
  17. Jiminez v the Queen 173 Commonwealth Law Reports 572 FC 92/012, 1992
  18. Girling v Howden 3 Dominion Law Reports 262, 1949
  19. Kay v Mills 28 Dominion Law Reports (2d) 554, 1961
  20. McCutcheon JP. Involuntary conduct and the case of the unconscious ««driver»»: reflections on Jiminez. Criminal Law Journal. 1997;21:71–79
  21. Kroon 52 ACrimR 15, 1990
  22. Virgo v Elding South Australian Supreme Court Reports 294, 1939
  23. Reyner LA, Horne JA. Falling asleep whilst driving: are drivers aware of prior sleepiness?. Int J Legal Med. 1998;111:120–123
  24. Staysafe 46, Falling asleep at the wheel—legal and licensing implications of driver fatigue. Report 19/51, 1998
  25. Crimes Act, 1900, (NSW)
  26. Gray, R, Deputy Solicitor NSW Office of the Department of Public Prosecutions Staysafe 46. 8 out of 48 in an 18-month period
  27. R v Rowlinson 67 South Australian S Report 96, 1996; 24 MVR 19 R v Pellow (unreported) R v Mark Andrew Sadlier NSW Law Reports, 1995
  28. Smith v Lard South Australian Supreme Court Report 88, 1962
  29. Gordon v Wallace 42 Dominion Law Reports (3rd) 342, 1973
  30. Britts, MMG, Traffic Law (New South Wales) (Sydney: LBC Information Services 7thEd, 1998) (2.2070)Robinson v Glover NZ Law Reports 669, 1952
  31. Callinan, I, Legal Issues: sleep apnoea and road safety, 1993, In Lake RIE (ed). Proceeding of a seminar on sleep disorders and road safety. Qld Transport Report RUB 93–1 24–36
  32. Motor Traffic Amendment (Driving Hours) Regulation 1998 (NSW)
  33. Wallace, M, Health Care and the Law. Sydney: The Law Book Company, 1995
  34. Occupational Health and Safety Act 1983 (NSW) s9–11
  35. Occupational Health and Safety (CE) Act (Cth)
  36. Johnstone, R, Occupational Health and Safety Law and Policy Sydney: The Law Book Company, 1995
  37. TNT Management Pty Ltd v Brown 23 MVR 240, 1996
  38. Trindade, F, Cane, P, Law of Torts in Australia, 2nd edition. Melbourne: Oxford University Press, 1993
  39. National Road Transport Commission, Sleep Disorder, Driving Fatigue and Safe Driving, Melbourne, April 1993; Queensland Transport, November, 1993; Stay Safe 28 Seminar, Parliament House Sydney, 1994
  40. National Road Transport Commission Act, 1991 (Cth)
  41. National Roads and Transport Commission, Medical Examinations of Commercial Vehicle Drivers, November, 1994
  42. Walsleben JA. The measurement of daytime wakefulness. Chest. 1992;101:890–891
  43. Bennett, J, Insuring for sleep disorders, In Staysafe report 1/51. Sleep Disorders, Driving Fatigue and Safe Driving, 72–78, 1994
  44. Insurance Contracts Act, 1984 (Cth) s 21
  45. For example, Public Health Act, 1991 NSW s14
  46. Australian Professional Liability—Medical CCH Australia Ltd 40–100, 1998
  47. Taylor, JF, Medical Aspects of Fitness to Drive: a Guide for Medical Practitioners». London: HMSO, 1995
  48. O»Keefe R. Sleep disorders in the law of torts. J Law Med. 1996;3:283–295
  49. Barbone F, MacMahon AD, Davey PG, Morris AD, Reid K, McDevith DG, et al. Association of road-traffic accidents with benzodiazepine use. Lancet. 1998;352:1331–1336
  50. O»Neil D. Benzodiazepine and driver safety. Lancet. 1998;352:1324–1325
  51. Australian Medical Association, Code of Ethics, 1996
  52. X v Y [1988] 2 All England Reports 649 at 653
  53. Skene, L, Law and Medical Practice, Sydney: Butterworths, 1998
  54. Intergovernment Committee on AIDS, Legal Working Party, Final Report, November 1992, 12–13 Recommendation 2.2
  55. Tarasoff v Regents of the University of California 1 [1974] 118 Californian Reports 129; 529 P2d 553
  56. Mendelson D. Could Tarasoff happen in Australia. J Psychiatr Law. 1991;19:38–59
  57. Thompson I v County of Alameda I2d 728 (1980) Palmer v Tees Health Authority and Another Court of Appeal (Unreported) July 1999
  58. W v Edgell [1990] 1All England Reports 835 (CA) at 848 Duncan v Medical. Practitioners Disciplinary Committee[1986]1NZ Law Reports 513 (NZHC)
  59. Magnussen RS, Opie H. HIV and Hepatitis in Sport: a legal framework for resolving hard cases. Monash Universit Law Rev. 1994;20:214–270
  60. Duncan v Medical Practitioners Disciplinary Committee [1986]1 NZ Law Reports 513 (NZHC)
  61. Road Safety Act 1986 (Vic) s 27(5)
  62. Previously Motor Traffic Act 1935 (NSW) s 17A which was repealed in 1998; now Road Transport (Driver Licensing) Act 1998 (NSW) s31
  63. Motor Traffic Regulations 1935 (NSW) s11 (1)
  64. Abadee A. The medical duty of confidentiality and prospective duty of disclosure: can they co-exist?. J Law Med. 1995;3:75–92
  65. Drivers and Riders: Guidelines for Medical Practi- tioners. NSW Road Traffic Authority 3rdEdition, 1993
  66. Assessing Fitness to Drive (Austroads Publication No. AP–56/98, 1998)
  67. W v Egdell [1990] 1 All England Reports 835 (CA)
  68. George CF, Smiley A. Sleep apnea and automobile crashes. Sleep. 1999;22:790–795
  69. Findley LJ, Bonnie RJ. Sleep apnea and automobile crashes. Chest. 1988;94:225–226
  70. Findley LJ, Fabrizio MJ, Thommi G, Surrat PM. Severity of sleep apnea and automobile crashes. N Englj Med. 1989;320:868–869
  71. Engleman H, Joffe D. Neuropsychological function in obstructive sleep apnoea. Sleep Med Rev. 1999;3:59–79
  72. ATS/ASDA . Statement on Health Outcomes Research in Sleep Apnea. Am J Crit Care Med. 1998;157:335–341
  73. George CF, Boudreau AC, Smiley A. Effects of nasal CPAP on simulated driving performance in patients with obstructive sleep apnoea. Thorax. 1997;52:648–653
  74. Cassel W, Ploch T, Becker C, Dugnus D, Peter JH, von Wichert P. Risk of traffic accidents in patients with sleep-disordered breathing: reduction with nasal CPAP. Euro Respir J. 1996;9:2606–2611

☆ Correspondence should be addressed to: E. Ellis, Faculty of Health Sciences, PO Box 170, Lidcombe, NSW 1825, Australia.

PII: S1087-0792(00)90132-1

doi: 10.1053/smrv.2000.0132

Sleep Medicine Reviews
Volume 5, Issue 1 , Pages 33-46 , February 2001

Article Tools